Planning beyond the shoreline

19 November 2026

Bringing the Coastal Marine Area into regional spatial planning requires more than extending the map offshore. It calls for an integrated view of land and sea, a longer planning horizon, and an informed conversation about what this shared space may need to provide over the coming decades.

The inclusion of the Coastal Marine Area in regional spatial planning creates a compelling opportunity to shape how Aotearoa New Zealand’s marine environment is used, protected and developed over the long term. With pressure on marine space increasing, the opportunity needs to be taken now.

The temptation is to treat this simply as an extension of land-based planning beyond the shoreline, but the marine environment demands a different way of thinking. As planner Stephanie Styles observes, “The shift with regional spatial planning is to lift our thinking to a more strategic level rather than primarily responding to particular activities or resource-management issues.”

The Coastal Marine Area’s distinct physical characteristics, patterns of use and public-good dimensions demand a different approach to both the planning process and the decisions that emerge from it.

From managing proposals to shaping the future

Councils are not starting from a blank page. Some regions have deliberately addressed particular coastal issues under the Resource Management Act 1991. Marlborough’s Aquaculture Marine Areas are one example, using defined spatial areas to support the regulatory framework. Cities and towns with ports also have experience planning for their operation and development.

Regional spatial planning changes the scale, perspective and timeframe. Rather than focusing on individual activities or resource-management issues, it can consider marine space as a whole and over a much longer planning horizon.

“We need to move from managing proposals to actively thinking about the future of the marine space,” Stephanie Styles says. Under the existing approach, attention often turns to the Coastal Marine Area when an activity is proposed, or when an environmental issue, conflict or controversy needs to be managed. Regional spatial planning allows councils, communities, iwi, marine industries and others with an interest in the Coastal Marine Area to ask a different question: what might this space need to provide for the region over the next 30 years?

Answering that question requires more than identifying where development should not occur. It also means considering where future infrastructure, economic activity and other regional opportunities might appropriately be enabled, while protecting places that are special, vulnerable or already under pressure.

Ecology as the foundation for informed choices

Ecology is crucial to effective marine spatial planning. Its role is to give everyone involved a fuller understanding of the marine environment, so decisions about future uses, protection and restoration are grounded in how marine ecosystems function.

This requires more than mapping habitats and species. Ecological information shows how marine ecosystems connect. Submarine canyons may provide feeding grounds for whales, seagrass meadows can act as nurseries for fish, and species may depend on several habitats over their lifecycles. Understanding these relationships helps reveal the wider consequences of decisions made in any one location.

Distribution also needs to be considered alongside historical change, current condition and likely future state. A habitat or species may be present on a map but already severely depleted or under pressure from human activities, climate change and other stressors. As marine ecologist Tommaso Alestra explains, “We need to understand not only where ecological features are, but how healthy they are and how they are likely to change in the future.” This broader picture can help determine where new activities may be appropriate, where protection is needed, and where opportunities exist to restore degraded ecosystems.

The ecological foundation for marine spatial planning will always be incomplete and involve uncertainty. Evidence is often patchy, and large parts of the marine environment remain poorly studied. These limitations need to be acknowledged openly, but an absence of records should not be treated as evidence that an area has little ecological value.

Ecological understanding comes not only from scientific papers, technical reports and spatial datasets. Mātauranga Māori, iwi and hapū knowledge, and the experience of local communities can provide essential insight into how marine environments have changed, how they are used and valued, and what may be needed to sustain them.

Bringing these forms of knowledge together will not eliminate uncertainty. It will, however, provide a stronger basis for deciding what the marine environment may need to support over the next 30 years, what should be protected, and where restoration could rebuild ecological health and resilience.

Recognising the sea as shared public space

A fundamental difference between planning on land and planning offshore is that the Coastal Marine Area is public space. Its use and occupation, accessibility and public-good dimensions need to be considered differently from privately owned land.

Marine areas support many overlapping public and private interests. They provide ecological habitat, customary and cultural connections, transport routes, recreation, food production, energy generation and infrastructure. Some activities require exclusive occupation, while others rely on continued public access or the maintenance of ecological processes across a much wider area.

This distinction should influence how spatial planning approaches opportunities as well as constraints. The task is not only to determine which activities may be technically possible, but to consider how different uses affect people’s ability to access, experience, value and depend on a shared marine environment.

Planning land and sea as one regional system

Although the Coastal Marine Area requires a distinct planning approach, it cannot be considered in isolation. Offshore activities invariably have relationships with what occurs on land.

Ports are an obvious example, but the same principle applies to marine farming, offshore energy, infrastructure corridors, recreation and responses to natural hazards. Regional spatial planning should make these connections visible rather than treating the shoreline as the boundary between two separate planning exercises. Marine infrastructure may depend on roads, energy networks and processing facilities, while changes to land use and freshwater systems within terrestrial catchments can influence water quality, sediment movement and ecological conditions offshore.

Rainfall carries sediment, nutrients and other contaminants from land into streams and rivers, and eventually into the sea. These flows can make coastal waters murkier, cover marine habitats and reduce the light available to marine life. Cyclone Gabrielle demonstrated the scale of these effects, with large volumes of sediment washing into coastal waters.

Development along coastal margins can create hard barriers, such as seawalls, that prevent seagrass meadows, saltmarshes and dunes from moving inland as sea levels rise. This “coastal squeeze” gradually reduces the space available for these habitats, weakening natural systems that support biodiversity, absorb wave energy and help coastal areas adjust to change.

"This is why land-based and marine activities, and the habitats they affect, need to be considered together. The marine environment cannot be fully understood or effectively planned for without recognising the land-based activities and coastal development patterns that influence it," says Tommaso Alestra. An integrated approach can align decisions across the land-sea boundary, enabling councils to consider how investment and intervention on land may support marine outcomes, and how offshore decisions may create infrastructure, environmental or community implications onshore.

Making choices before conflicts arise

Marine space faces increasingly significant choices and trade-offs. Ports, infrastructure crossing the Coastal Marine Area, offshore marine farming, natural gas, offshore wind and seabed resources place different and competing demands on the same space. Environmental, recreational, cultural and community values must also be considered.

Regional spatial planning provides an opportunity to bring those demands together before individual proposals expose the conflicts. This does not remove the need for subsequent regulatory processes or detailed environmental assessment. It can, however, establish a clearer strategic direction and identify where further investigation, engagement or evidence will be required.

The opportunity is broader than mapping constraints. Spatial plans can help regions identify where activities may offer long-term benefits, where multiple uses may be compatible, and where development could create unacceptable pressure on environmental or community values.

Assessing marine activities project by project can miss the bigger picture. An individual activity may have relatively localised effects, but impacts can accumulate over time and across a wider area. Existing pressures, nearby activities and the combined effects of future development may not be fully visible when each proposal is considered in isolation.

Marine activities also interact with environmental stressors. Sedimentation, poor water quality and climate change can place habitats under sustained pressure, reducing their ability to cope with additional human activities. Effects that appear manageable on their own can become more significant within an ecosystem that is already degraded or undergoing rapid change.

Used early in the spatial-planning process, ecological evidence can show where pressures are accumulating, where further activity could affect important or sensitive habitats, and where different uses may be appropriate or incompatible with ecological values. It can also identify opportunities to protect or restore the marine environment. The aim is to anticipate potential conflicts before locations and development pathways become entrenched, rather than reacting when individual proposals bring competing demands into direct conflict.

Understanding a three-dimensional environment

Marine space is three-dimensional. An activity may occupy or affect the sea surface, water column, seabed or airspace above. Something that cannot be seen from land may still represent an important opportunity or a significant environmental effect.

This is one reason conventional land-based spatial-planning thinking cannot simply be carried offshore. Different activities may occupy different layers, but the boundaries between them are not ecological boundaries. Seabed dredging can generate sediment plumes in the water column, while organic material from marine farms can settle on the seabed. Seabirds move between the air, sea surface and water column, connecting parts of the environment that may appear separate on a map.

Different activities may sometimes coexist within the same horizontal area because they occupy different parts of this three-dimensional space. Ships can transit above sensitive seabed habitats, and mid-water fishing can occur above reefs without directly disturbing them. Anchoring, dredging and bottom trawling, by contrast, interact directly with the seabed and may damage these habitats. Understanding these differences can reveal opportunities to share marine space as well as potential conflicts between uses and ecological values.

The ecological importance of an area can also vary with depth and over time. Fish may use shallow coastal habitats as nursery areas when juvenile, before moving into deeper waters as adults. Particular areas may become important at different times of year for spawning, feeding, breeding or migration. Spatial planning therefore needs to consider how species use different habitats and parts of the marine environment throughout the year and at successive stages of their life cycles.

A first-generation spatial plan may not represent all these relationships in detail, but it should acknowledge them and avoid treating the sea as a flat surface or a series of disconnected layers. Planning must consider not only where an activity takes place, but its full footprint and effects, including how these may extend beyond its immediate location.

Setting direction in the face of uncertainty

The first generation of regional spatial plans will have to deal honestly with uncertainty. Councils will not have perfect information about marine environments, future technologies or emerging uses of marine space.

These first-generation plans need to set strategic directions and identify opportunities for further investigation without suggesting that every future activity can already be mapped. This will give subsequent iterations a foundation on which to build as understanding improves and regional priorities evolve.

There is an important tension between flexibility and environmental protection. Plans that are too prescriptive could unintentionally close off beneficial activities that cannot yet be anticipated. Plans that are too open may provide inadequate environmental direction and defer difficult choices until individual proposals arise.

Objectives and policy direction that preserves appropriate future choices while maintaining clear protection for important environmental values will require sound evidence, transparent decision-making, and a willingness to revisit assumptions over time.

Ultimately, regional spatial planning for the Coastal Marine Area is about the future of a shared space. It needs to encompass the people who use, value and depend on that space, including those whose activities are based on land. Environmental, economic, infrastructure, cultural, recreational and community perspectives must be brought together when deciding what should be enabled, what requires protection, and where.